The thinking behind ProductiveQ

Clarity
from complexity.

Most organisations did not choose to be complicated. They grew, and each new rule, role and system made sense on the day it was added.

ProductiveQ rests on six ideas about how to undo that. They draw on co-founder Howard Thomas’s work at TAM Consultants, founded to bring clarity from complexity.

PQ / Study 03The contagion of complexity
How complexity feeds itself A cycle of six stages. Growth leads to more management, then more systems, then more data, then complexity, then pressure on productivity, which brings pressure for more growth. GrowthMore is expected ManagementMore to coordinate SystemsMore to administer DataMore to reconcile ComplexityLess is clear ProductivityUnder pressure EACH ADDITIONFEEDS THE NEXT
Simplified from TAM Consultants’ “contagion of complexity”. Illustrative.

01 / Any fool can add

Complexity is added.
Rarely chosen.

Growth brings more management. More management brings more systems. More systems bring more data. Each addition is reasonable. Together they slow the work they were meant to support.

TAM Consultants calls this the contagion of complexity. Howard Thomas’s book sums it up in four words: any fool can add.

The alternative is to ask what can be eliminated, substituted, minimised or simplified before adding anything.

See the four questions

02 / Simple is not shallow

Simplifying is not
dumbing down.

Reducing complexity takes more understanding, not less. You need to know a subject well to see which parts matter and which can go.

03 / Function, not form

Start with what
the business does.

An organisation chart shows form: who reports to whom. A function map shows what the business must do to succeed, whoever does it. Settle the functions first. Structure can follow.

PQ / Study 04 · The original function map

An oil and gas business, by function.

01LeadSets direction. Defining this group well can add the most value.
  • Operational Excellence
  • Capital Discipline
  • Grow Your Own Timber
  • Stakeholder Communication
  • Protect People and Planet
02CoreDelivers the main work, from first step to last.
  • Exploration
  • Drilling
  • Develop
  • Produce
  • Abandon
03HelpSupports the core with guidance, information, supplies and customers.
  • Provide Business Guidance
  • Provide Information
  • Provide Equipment & Supplies
  • Provide Customers
  • Provide Technical Guidance
Redrawn from the function map published by TAM Consultants.ProductiveQ’s demo maps the same kind of business. The third group is now called Enable. Open the demo map

“It is my belief that it is of the very essence of every problem that it contains and suggests its own solution.”

Louis Sullivan, architect, 1896

In an established industry the core functions are well known, and the supporting ones are easy to name. Defining the leadership functions well is where the most value can be added.

No two businesses have quite the same functions, so no two maps should match. Doing what competitors do is comfortable, but it is not analysis.

04 / From data to decisions

More data is not
more understanding.

A record on its own is data. Connected to the step it supports, the person responsible and the system that holds it, it becomes information. Patterns across those connections are knowledge. Judging what to do about them is wisdom, and that stays with people.

  1. Data
    As recorded

    Owners, dates, versions and permissions, as source systems hold them.

  2. Information
    In relation

    Each record linked to the step, role and system it supports.

  3. Knowledge
    In patterns

    Overdue reviews, missing owners and repeated work, seen across the map.

  4. Wisdom
    In judgement

    A responsible person weighs the evidence and decides.

PQ / Study 05Four levels of understanding
From data to wisdom Four levels rise along two axes, connectedness and understanding. Data becomes information by understanding relations, knowledge by understanding patterns and wisdom by understanding principles. Data Information Knowledge Wisdom + relations + patterns + principles UNDERSTANDING CONNECTEDNESS
Each level adds understanding to the one below. Illustrative.

05 / Room to perform

Control everything
and nothing moves.

An object held in every direction cannot move. An organisation that tries to control every outcome at once, from safety and quality to profit and compliance, leaves its people no room to solve problems.

PQ / Study 06No degrees of freedom
Work constrained from every direction Six constraints press in on the work from all sides: safety, quality, reliability, efficiency, profit and compliance. With every direction held, the work cannot move. WORK Safety Quality Reliability Efficiency Profit Compliance
Held in every direction, nothing moves. Illustrative.

The answer is clarity, not more control

  1. 01

    Clear purpose.

    Strategy says which opportunities to pursue and which risks to manage.

  2. 02

    Clear process.

    Policy turns strategy into rules. Process carries them out. When the three line up, people can see why their work exists.

  3. 03

    Empowered people.

    People are assets, not resources. Set goals, invest in people’s understanding and let them find the best way there.

ProductiveQ follows the same rule. It shows the connections and the evidence. Your authorised people decide and carry out changes.

06 / Knowledge is an asset

An asset has to
earn its keep.

Nobody wants an asset for its own sake. They want the value it produces. Knowledge is no different. A record that a step relies on is an asset. A record that nothing depends on is a cost.

Further reading

Simplicity from
Complexity.

Howard Thomas’s book shows how organisations can start to undo the complexity they have built up. It is told as a fable: a young woman’s journey from complexity towards simplicity, with a cast familiar to anyone who has spent time in industry.

It was partly inspired by Stephen Hawking’s remark in 2000 that the next century would be the century of complexity. All profits support the Eddie and Elizabeth Thomas Scholarship Fund, which helps disadvantaged students study engineering at the University of Newcastle upon Tyne.

Put it to work

Start with
the map.

The ideas are simple. Applying them takes a clear view of the work. We’ll show you the function map, then discuss how the method could apply to your business.